Katt Williams Is Right About Jehovah’s Witnesses. That’s the Problem.
Comedian Katt Williams recently went on one of the most popular podcasts in the world and said his Jehovah's Witness parents beat him so badly and so often that some mornings he was unconscious in a bathtub before school. Then he did something I didn't expect. He defended the religion.
What he said about Jehovah's Witnesses is actually correct, and that should worry anyone still inside. A religion can condemn beating a child and still build every wall needed to keep that abuse hidden. Later I'll show you a practicing, believing Witness writing in 2025 who describes a mother holding her daughter's head in a flushing toilet, and then explains why the elders didn't need to report it as child abuse.
"The Religion Wasn't Condoning This"
When host Steven Bartlett asked Williams why he had called his parents "allegedly" Jehovah's Witnesses, he answered:
Well, because this isn't in anybody's religious framework, you know, like they weren't doing this to stay in good graces of the religion. like the religion wasn't condoning this. Even then, nobody thought you could beat a child half to death on a weekly basis to the point where they're unconscious in a bathtub before school and you're having to try to get them to where they can um where the bleeding will stop so they can go to school. Like, no religion condones that. But we were high up in the religion and an example to a lot of people and so it was necessary that I do a better acting job or give in.
I almost never react to social media. I rarely cover anything Watchtower didn't post or publish itself, because that's where the real evidence about the institution is. Sometimes rank-and-file members do things the organization doesn't agree with, and that doesn't reflect on it as a whole. But Williams made a point that very few people seem to be taking seriously: the religion wasn't condoning this. And he's right. On paper, it doesn't.
Williams grew up in Dayton, Ohio, and was on The Diary of a CEO to promote his new memoir. What he says about his Jehovah's Witness upbringing explains something every ex-Witness eventually has to face.
I was born and raised a Jehovah's Witness and spent 40 years in the religion. I have never known a Witness who thought child abuse, physical or sexual, was okay. Not one. And I've never met a Witness who, asked straight out whether child abuse should be covered up, would say yes. That is the real problem. Witnesses know the right thing to do when they come across abuse. In my view, it's when Watchtower's culture machine kicks in that they're pressured into the terrible decisions they're known for. This article is about that machine, not the theology.
Refusing to Live a Double Life
Bartlett asked whether the abuse came from his mother, his father, or both. "Evenly," Williams said. Then he explained why:
In order for me to live this religious life that I was set up to live, it meant that I had to be 100% invested and I had to act the way that I believed. And early on, I had decided that I wasn't going to live a double life.
Asked again whether his parents were Jehovah's Witnesses, he said: "Allegedly. Could have been Scientologists, but yes, I wasn't going to live a double life."
Every ex-Witness knows what he means. He's describing being PIMO: physically in, mentally out. You smile at the meetings and answer when you're supposed to, but you don't believe a word of it. Williams says that as a little kid he refused to do that. He wasn't going to fake it. In his house, he says, the price of not faking it was a beating.
Mornings in the Bathtub
This is how he describes the mornings:
Well, we had like an hour to play with sometimes as far as um what just happened and now I'm in no shape to be getting ready for a school day. But we got to get the bleeding to stop and we got to, you know, Epsom salts, I believe, just so we can get a good scab on so he can afford to put his clothes on and get on off to school. Cuz no matter what happened, I was never missing school. School was like everything in my world. just to get a chance to be out of this situation and in a different situation where they don't even know that that situation took place. Like that's why I look happy in all the school pictures.
What strikes me is how practical his parents were about it, as he tells it. How strategic. Stop the bleeding. Get the Epsom salts. Get a good scab so he can put his clothes on and go to school. And at school, "they don't even know that that situation took place." The hiding was built into his morning routine. Nobody had to order him to keep quiet. It was understood. The whole household was organized around the fact that nobody outside could ever know.
He says the beatings went on for hours. Early on, he deliberately made enough noise for the neighbors next door, an older white couple who loved him, to hear what he was going through. When he saw them years later, he says, they were crestfallen: "We just didn't understand what was going on because we would hear it for hours and hours at night. And then we would see you at 7:00 a.m. and you'd be all dressed and smiling and on your way to school like it didn't happen."
The neighbors heard it for hours and then saw a smiling kid heading to school, and they didn't understand what they were looking at. But another group of people saw his family every week: their congregation. Williams says, "we were high up in the religion and an example to a lot of people." Elsewhere he says, "Outwardly they were perfect. Everything they presented was a perfect view of what you would think it should be. There were just things behind the scenes that were terrible."
He's making two separate points. First, the religion doesn't condone what his parents did. That's true, and I'll prove it from Watchtower's own words. Second, his family was an example to a lot of people, so he had to pretend and act. The second point is what this article is about. The question isn't whether Watchtower approves of beating a child half to death and sending him to school. It doesn't. The question is how a family that looked perfect to the Kingdom Hall could keep it up for seven years, from age 5 until he was 12, by his account, and why the people who finally stopped it came from outside the religion.
What Watchtower Has Put in Print About Child Abuse
Over the years Watchtower has put in print, more than once, that what Williams describes is wrong. In 1976, Awake! ran a whole issue on child abuse. It said:
Paul's counsel to fathers would rule out brutal beatings or other physical torture.
The 2002 book Draw Close to Jehovah says:
The rod of discipline should never be abusive emotionally or physically.
The Secret of Family Happiness (1996) says:
A person who repeatedly and unrepentantly gives in to violent fits of anger, perhaps including physical abuse of spouse or children, can be disfellowshipped.
They printed the right answer on reporting too. The May 2019 Watchtower asks:
What happens if somebody reports abuse and it becomes known in the community? Should the Christian who reported it feel that he has brought reproach on God's name?
The answer is no. The abuser is the one who brings reproach on God's name. That article is about sexual abuse, but the principle is correct. And the current elders' manual, the 2025 edition of Shepherd the Flock of God, puts it in five words:
Child abuse is a crime.
So on paper, the religion does not condone the kind of abuse Williams describes. If you had stopped any Witness in his family's Kingdom Hall parking lot and asked, I have no doubt they'd have said the same.
Despite all that, by his account, Williams still ended up bleeding in a bathtub in a house that was "an example to a lot of people." In the end it took a school and the police to stop it. So if everybody knows the right answer, what went wrong, here and in the countless other cases that have landed Watchtower in court?
I think it comes down to why Watchtower does what it does. In my view, everything in the culture of Jehovah's Witnesses is built to protect the organization's image and keep people inside. When you look at the pressures on Witnesses who suspect something is wrong in a family, they all point the same way: protect the organization at all costs. Watchtower prints the correct answers, but the cultural pressure runs the other way.
There are five of these pressures, each on a different person who could have stopped it: the child, the parents, the congregation, the elders, and every Witness who might hear about it later. Any one of them sounds almost harmless. Stacked together, they make "I know this is wrong" almost always end with "but I can't tell anybody."
Pressure One: Children Taught to Fear the People Who Could Help
Williams left home at 13. Bartlett called it running away. Williams corrected him:
I didn't run away. It was only a matter of time before the authorities were involved and that's just how it happened. Like I I never said anything to anyone. My parents never said anything. It was wonderful. Blessed administrators at school that um noticed that the guy who loved nothing more than gym physical education wasn't dressing out for gym sometimes. And they found that to be odd and unlike him. So, you know, the police were called to the school. They did uh an investigation, took pictures, and the plan was that they were going to come to our house the next day and make arrests. And so I I needed to not be there when that happened so that my younger brothers had a chance.
When Bartlett asked what the police photographs showed, he said he was "covered in um extension cord wounds… you can see the progression from the extension cords to the water hose."
The elders didn't notice, and neither did anyone at the Kingdom Hall. It was the school administrators, people from the outside world, who noticed that a kid who loved gym class didn't want to change for it.
Then Bartlett asked what I think is the most important question in the interview: did he want the police to know?
No. But um I I didn't have a way of proving to myself that this is egregious and outside the way outside the norm. This is beyond the pale. this is um criminal. I didn't really have a frame for that, but they did and they were quite clear that it doesn't go like this. Like nobody gets to do this to a child and it doesn't matter what you did.
He says the police told him they would come to the house, arrest his parents, and move him and his brothers somewhere safe. He asked whether they could promise his two younger brothers wouldn't be separated, since there was plenty of family in the city. They told him they couldn't guarantee that. Their job was to remove the kids, and the system would handle the rest. What he was trying to avoid, he said, was letting his situation ruin his brothers' situations.
Inside the world of Jehovah's Witnesses, by his account, there was no category for what was happening to him. He "didn't really have a frame for that." Outside, the police had a word for it: criminal. But the people who had that frame, teachers and police, are exactly the people Witness kids are taught to see as part of Satan's world. That's not an exaggeration.
Williams is 55, so this 1973 Watchtower article on raising children came out not long before his childhood. It says:
Worldly authorities on rearing children frequently say, "No, the child should never be spanked."
Its answer is that correcting your child, including spanking him, is the loving thing to do. This is God's way.
Fifteen years later, look at how the branch framed child abuse itself. In 1988 a confidential letter about child molestation went to every body of elders in Canada. Before saying anything about what elders should do, it said:
This is further evidence of the depravity of many in the world around us.
So child abuse was filed as a problem out there in the world, not something that happens in here, at least not through any fault of the organization or its policies. That language hasn't gone anywhere. A 2020 Watchtower study article asks parents:
Do I do my best to protect my children from the physical and moral dangers that they may encounter in Satan's world?
That's still how Witnesses describe everyone outside the Kingdom Hall: Satan's world, under Satan's control.
In December 2022, Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare issued guidance on child abuse connected to religious beliefs. It names no particular religion, but it says that frightening a child by calling the child's friends or teachers Satan is a form of psychological abuse. Think about why a government would feel the need to write that down. In a survey from a group of Japanese lawyers, which I'll come back to, more than a third of former Witness children who were kept away from non-Witness friends, 38%, said the religion called those friends Satan.
On the ex-JW subreddit, a user named Tacos for Tuesday described what that fear looked like. They said they were kept home from school repeatedly because they had too many visible bruises from a leather belt, and that doctor's appointments were cancelled for the same reason. Their parents sat them and their brother down and warned them never to talk to teachers, doctors, or police "because they were part of Satan's system and would take us away."
The people who could actually help these children are the people they're taught to fear. When something goes wrong at home, the outside world isn't a rescue. It's a threat from the Devil. But fearing outsiders only matters if there's something to hide from them. That brings us to the second pressure, which sits on the parents.
Pressure Two: The Rod as a Duty Before God
Early in the interview, Williams says his parents "believed in spare the rod, spoil the child." Many people responding to the interview have pointed out, correctly, that spanking was normal in America in the 1970s and '80s. Lots of parents did it, not just Witnesses.
What's more specific to Jehovah's Witnesses is this. Watchtower didn't just allow spanking, which it called the rod. It taught it from the platform as God's direction. But the line between discipline and abuse was left entirely to the parent holding the belt.
Go back to that 1976 Awake! issue on child abuse that ruled out brutal beatings. One page earlier it asks whether spanking is entirely out of place and answers, "not at all." It quotes:
With the rod you yourself should beat him.
And on the same page it says:
Studies have shown that the overwhelming majority of child abusers are parents who overdiscipline.
So in an issue about child abuse, on one page Watchtower tells parents to use the rod and admits that most child abusers are parents who overdo exactly that. On the next page it rules out brutal beatings. What it never says is where the line is. That's left to the parent.
Watchtower left it to the parent how far to go. It did not leave it to the parent whether to use the rod at all. Watchtower's Bible encyclopedia, Insight on the Scriptures (1988), says the rod includes:
the literal rod used for chastisement
It says the parent is responsible before God to exercise this rod, and that if the parent fails in this:
he will bring ruination and death to his child and disgrace and God's disapproval to himself also.
So the parent is on the hook. Use the rod, or you're the one who brings disgrace. Williams comes back to this at the very end.
This was so well understood when I was growing up that a 1980 Watchtower could open an article with a story about a little girl misbehaving at the Kingdom Hall. Her father leads her toward a small room at the rear of the hall, and she cries out, "Oh Jehovah, please help." The article then says:
Whenever this incident is related, it elicits chuckles.
Williams was 8 years old when that was published. If you grew up anywhere like I did, everyone knew what the back room was for. We heard the spanks and smacks during meetings when kids acted up, which they often did. Make a child sit through hours of boring meetings with no Sunday school and they'll get antsy. Where I grew up, antsy kids got beaten.
The Japanese Survey: 92% Whipped as Children
The best data on how widespread this was comes from Japan. In November 2023, the group of Japanese lawyers I mentioned published a survey of people raised as Jehovah's Witnesses. It was self-selected, and most respondents had already left the religion, so it isn't a random sample. Of 560 people, 514, or 92%, said they were whipped as children, and 57% said they were whipped inside the Kingdom Hall itself.
The year before, when a newspaper asked Watchtower about whipping in 2022, the organization said discipline methods were up to each household and that if some parents did use corporal punishment, that was regrettable. That brings us back to Williams: the religion wasn't condoning this. Going by Watchtower's answer to that newspaper, that appears to be true. They blamed the household. It was the household's choice. They placed no blame on the platform, the magazines, or the small room at the back of the hall.
According to the lawyers' report, a couple of months later the branch told the newspaper it had heard that whipping happened in the 1990s on what it called a "mistaken interpretation," and that since the 2000s it had been working to correct that. Mistaken by whom? In the same survey, more than half said the instruction to whip came from the platform.
The lawyers also interviewed an active Jehovah's Witness elder and quoted his written statement, translated from Japanese:
Watchtower's 2023 notice to members states, "We do not condone child abuse," but it does not clearly admit that the whip discipline it used to recommend was wrong.
That's an active elder, still inside, saying what I'm saying. Not condoning something and owning it are two very different things.
"Do It Someplace More Quiet"
What did congregations tell parents once the beatings started getting noticed? A user on the ex-JW subreddit, Miss Rachel, said parents at one hall were told to stop using the bathroom for discipline because it echoed. They added:
Not told to quit beating their kids with belts, wooden spoons, rulers, etc., just to do it someplace more quiet.
Today's Watchtower sounds very different. A 1992 Awake! says the rod suggests "loving guidance, not harsh brutality." A 2006 Watchtower says the Bible is against "violence and abuse of any sort," though it still says the rod is at times literal. I'll grant them that the modern wording is much better. But in a lot of halls, the message parents heard wasn't "stop." It was "be quiet about it."
I know this firsthand. One of the halls I grew up in had a tile-floored bathroom that echoed, parents took their kids back there to beat them, and it became a problem. That Reddit user isn't alone. And telling people to be quiet about it is where this gets really dangerous, because the next pressure turns silence into a spiritual duty.
Pressure Three: The Model Family Everyone Is Watching
The third pressure sits on the whole family, with the whole congregation watching. Remember what Williams said at the start: "We were high up in the religion and an example to a lot of people. So, it was necessary that I do a better acting job or give in." In another interview, on Club Shay, he put it this way: "I'm supposed to at least religiously hold down the family's name."
Anyone who was a Witness knows what he means. In the congregation, a family isn't just a family. It's the father's résumé. A 1978 Watchtower on whether a man qualifies to serve says:
if one minor child after another brings reproach on the family in the congregation, there is serious question as to whether the father is presiding over his household in a fine way.
That hasn't changed. When elders decide whether to recommend a brother, the 2025 elders' manual asks:
Are he and his family exemplary in their conduct?
In Witness culture, that means: are they doing everything the way Watchtower says? So the kids carry their father's standing on their backs. If they act up, his record is on the line. If something ugly happens at home and people find out, his record is on the line, and the family's whole place in the congregation goes with it, with serious social consequences.
Witnesses are trained from birth not to air things. A 1957 Watchtower about gossip asks:
Will your exposing his nakedness and shame to others add to the respect to our mother?
The "mother" there is the organization, which has its own problems. That article is about gossip, not calling the police, but the reflex it builds is the same: you don't expose a brother's shame. You protect the organization's reputation and keep it inside. They call that not bringing reproach on Jehovah's name, as if what the organization does reflects on God. To a Witness, it absolutely does. So they avoid anything that brings reproach, because it reflects badly on their family, on the congregation, and on God himself.
One Reddit user whose father was an elder wrote:
In public, we were the perfect witness family. exemplary, spiritual, active PIMIs.
That means physically and mentally in, true believers. Then the user said they were:
Good robots who never told anyone what was actually happening at home.
This isn't only American. In 2022, a Japanese research group called Cheeky Lab surveyed people raised in religious homes and found a pattern: the perfect parent at meetings or church services, the violent one at home. It happened in other religions too, not just among Jehovah's Witnesses. But one respondent wrote, in translation, that their parents were an elder and an overseer, so both had to set an example, that their father's corporal punishment was harsh, and that it was painful both to act out a model family outside and to keep up a strict family Bible study at home.
Acting out a model family. That's the acting job Williams was talking about. As a little kid, he refused to live a double life. He wasn't going to be PIMO. But in a house like that, the double life isn't really optional. The whole family performs at the meeting, and the kid who won't play along becomes a problem. In his case, he says, that meant getting beaten.
Another Reddit user, Karen St. James, also an older child, posted a story much like his. They said their brother was beaten unconscious twice and their mother called the school with excuses for why he'd be gone for two weeks. "Poison Ivy was her favorite," they wrote. "That kept his friends away, too, so no one could see his black and blue face and body."
How the Family Image Explained Away a Disappearance
The family image did one more thing in Williams's story. The police had photographed his wounds and planned to come to the house the next day. Williams left that day. A year and a half later, he says, his family pulled over on the side of a highway in Florida and picked him up. He explained:
So we find out later on that when I leave that day, they leave the same day.
They moved the whole family to Florida that same day. As he put it:
So it never looked to my family or people that loved me. It never looked like I had left home. It looked like the family had moved. And because they were missionaries, people thought that was perfectly understandable.
Telling the same story on Michelle Obama's podcast, he was blunter: "These conniving parents of mine. Let's say I left on Sunday. They moved out of the city on Monday. So, no one knows I'm gone. My grandparents don't know. Nobody knows. Nobody thinks anything's wrong."
He's right that this is perfectly normal in a congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses. For decades Watchtower has encouraged families to pick up and move to where they say there's a greater need for preachers. A 1984 Awake! quotes a Gilead graduate explaining how she started:
When the series of Watchtower magazine articles came out encouraging people to go to Central America, my dad moved and we went down as a family.
That happened routinely my entire 40 years in the organization. So when a family he says was an example to a lot of people suddenly leaves the state, nobody asks what they're running from. They assume it's for the ministry. The image did its job. It explained away the disappearance to everyone who would have loved that little boy.
All of this is awful, but you might think it's just one family, a few bad apples. Williams himself said the religion didn't condone it. So is it just a few families? Watchtower's own paperwork, the courts, and government inquiries on two other continents answer that.
Pressure Four: Elders Call the Lawyers First
The fourth pressure sits on the elders, and it turns a culture into a procedure. When something goes wrong, you don't call the police. You call Watchtower.
In July 1989, Watchtower sent a confidential letter to every body of elders in the United States. Under the heading "Child Abuse," it says:
When elders receive reports of physical or sexual abuse of a child, they should contact the Society's legal department immediately.
Notice that it includes physical abuse. A beaten child like Williams goes down the same pipe. The next sentence says victims need to be protected from further danger. The letter doesn't tell elders not to report. But look at who it says to call first: not child protection, the lawyers.
As recently as August 2016, Watchtower sent every body of elders a letter titled "Protecting Minors From Abuse." Paragraph 2 defines the term:
Child abuse includes the sexual or physical abuse of a minor.
That's the only place physical abuse comes up. Every procedure in the rest of the letter, how to help the victim, what to do about the accused, what to file and where, is written for sexual abuse. A beaten child is in the definition but outside everything that's supposed to follow from it.
Look at the frame around it, too. The same letter warns elders that:
worldly persons are quick to resort to lawsuits if they feel their rights have been violated.
A couple of pages later, a bold heading says:
Do not make statements to secular authorities until you receive legal advice from the Society.
From 2019 through 2024, the elders' manual opened its chapter on child abuse by telling elders that following its direction would:
uphold the sanctity of Jehovah's name and contribute toward the safety of minors.
Jehovah's name comes first in that sentence. The child's safety comes after.
The 2025 edition dropped that sentence but kept who you call first. Its chapter on child abuse says elders comply with reporting laws and should tell victims they're free to go to the authorities. The next paragraph says:
When the elders learn of an allegation of child abuse, even if the alleged abuse occurred many years ago, two elders should immediately call the Service Department.
That chapter's definition of child abuse includes physical abuse too. So in 2026, a beaten child still means a call to the branch first.
A Believer Explains Why a Flushing Toilet Didn't Need Reporting
What does this procedure look like when it's a beating rather than molestation? In 2025, a believer posted on JW Talk, a forum only for active Witnesses. They described a case in their own congregation where a mother held her daughter upside down by the feet over the commode, with the girl's hair in the water, and then flushed it.
They said it constituted abuse under local law, but that the congregation elders followed the branch's instructions and "avoided unnecessary problems with local authorities."
Unnecessary problems with local authorities. That's how a believer describes keeping the police away from a girl whose head was held in a flushing toilet. When another member pushed back, the original poster explained why it was fine:
This was not a case of sexual abuse. Since it was physical abuse, under local law, there was not a requirement to report it.
In their mind, a beating just wasn't important enough to report. It's the same kind of house Williams describes and the same silence that keeps it going.
What the Sexual Abuse Record Reveals About the Machine
To see whether this is just one or a few congregations, look at where most of the records of this machine live: the sexual abuse cases. It's a different kind of abuse, but it falls under the same letter, the same phone call, and the same claimed concern for Jehovah's name, which in my view really means the organization's reputation. If the machine stays quiet about a molester, think how easy it is to stay quiet about a child hit with a belt.
An Elder Under Oath in Montana
James Roland was an elder in Harden, Montana. Two of his own children sued Watchtower over abuse they said happened in that congregation. In a 2021 deposition, he was asked whether he would have gone to the police. He said:
I would have went outside of the organization, but see, I believe totally in the footsteps of Jesus Christ. And on the one hand, I didn't want to drag Jehovah's name in because I knew there was a process for handling this. And secondly, I knew that if I did and they did it to me anyhow, I'd have been like an apostate.
That's an honest description, under oath, of the machine I'm describing. He knew the right thing to do, "I would have went outside of the organization," but two pressures stopped him: Jehovah's name and the fear of being treated like an apostate.
Australia's Royal Commission
On the other side of the world, Australia's Royal Commission into child sexual abuse reported on Jehovah's Witnesses in 2016. In one case, a local elder and the circuit overseer wrote to the branch recommending that the accused man be made an elder again "once this has died down." The elder was worried that "there may also be worldly people who also know," and he conceded that his concern was probably not about protecting the children in the congregation. The Commission found that the elders were more concerned about the reputation of the congregation and Jehovah than about the risk the man posed to children.
In 2014, when the survivor in that case was considering going to the Royal Commission, another elder asked her husband:
What would that accomplish other than dragging Jehovah's name through the mud?
Dragging Jehovah's name through the mud. Roland in Montana: "I didn't want to drag Jehovah's name in." Two elders on two continents saying almost exactly the same thing.
Watchtower Australia held files on 1,006 alleged perpetrators, and the Royal Commission found no evidence that the organization had reported a single one of them to police. Watchtower's own review said 383 had been dealt with by authorities, but it never said Watchtower was the one who reported them. The Commission's conclusion was blunt:
It is the general practice of the Jehovah's Witness organization in Australia not to report allegations of child sexual abuse to the police or other authorities unless required to do so by law.
The Dutch Government Study
In Europe, in 2020, Utre University published a study of Jehovah's Witnesses in the Netherlands for the Dutch Ministry of Justice. The researchers saw the same gap I've been describing:
writings within the Jehovah's Witness community clearly state that attention must be paid to the victims of sexual abuse. However, we also noted that in practice, a great deal of attention is paid to the perpetrators or alleged perpetrators.
The victims they interviewed who had told only their parents and the elders gave reasons why none of them went to the police: the inwardly oriented culture of the Jehovah's Witness community, and the biblical principle that you shouldn't take your brother to court. The right words were on paper. The culture pushed the other way.
Watchtower's Own Brief in New York
In a court brief filed in New York in January 2026, Watchtower's own lawyer wrote:
Watchtower readily concedes that during the abuse period, it did not have a policy for the protection of children.
They argued they didn't need one because congregations didn't run activities that separated children from their parents. Set that next to Williams's story. The danger was never in a Sunday school or a youth program. It was in the home.
Now put his family in this picture. A family he says was an example to a lot of people. An organization that, within a few years of his leaving, put in writing that the first call when a child is beaten goes to the lawyers, not the police or child protection. And a kid who, in his words, "didn't really have a frame for" what was happening, in a system where nobody was going to give him one.
The Other Side of the Record
Watchtower would point to the other side of this record, and it's real. Watchtower has won some of these cases. A $35 million verdict in Montana was reversed because the court found that Montana's clergy exemption made the legal department's advice lawful there. Most of Watchtower's settlements admit nothing. And the 2025 elders' manual does tell elders that victims are free to report.
I couldn't find any instruction in anything Watchtower wrote for elders telling them not to report abuse. I looked. But that's my point. They never had to say it. Protecting Jehovah's name, protecting the organization's image, the fear they build of the outside world, and that first phone call to the legal department did all the work. They didn't have to tell anyone not to report.
Pressure Five: Don't Look
Everything here is on the public record on four continents: courts, a royal commission, a government study, sworn depositions, and Watchtower's own briefs. So why doesn't the average Jehovah's Witness know any of it? That's the last pressure. It sits on every Witness and keeps the whole thing sealed. In two words: don't look.
In 1986, The Watchtower compared apostate material to pornography. If a parent would protect their kids from pornography, it reasoned, shouldn't God protect us from apostasy? It says, "Keep away from it." In Watchtower theology, an apostate is anyone who leaves the religion and openly disagrees with it.
In 1994, The Watchtower admitted that apostates "may also present certain facts," but said those facts are usually taken out of context, and still warned Witnesses not to read their writings. In 2011, it called apostates "mentally diseased" and said, "We also refuse to read their literature." A 2021 Watchtower says apostates have spread:
negative reports, half-truths, and outright lies about Jehovah's Witnesses through the news media and the Internet.
And the Enjoy Life Forever! course, which Witnesses study with people right now, says it's dangerous:
to read their books or blogs, to go to their websites, or to watch their videos.
One believer on JW Talk put it simply: "The GB direction to not read the material is for a reason."
The Japanese elder described what that does. After Japan's government published its child abuse guidance and the news covered it, he wrote, in translation:
Discussing the religious abuse Q&A, the media reports or the notice among members is taboo. No one talks about it. They're afraid of being regarded as apostates. So, activity inside the organization has not changed at all.
That creates a loop. Abuse is filed as the world's problem, out there in Satan's system, not in here. Any report of abuse inside the organization, whether from a royal commission, a newspaper, or a court record, is apostate lies and half-truths you're not allowed to read. So the believer never puts the pieces together. When something bad happens in their own congregation, it looks like a one-off, one bad family, because they've been taught not to look at all the other cases just like it.
If you're currently a Jehovah's Witness and you've read this far, you're already past that rule.
"How Much Pressure Must Have Been on Them"
Williams deserves the last word. Bartlett asked about his relationship with his parents, John and Brenda, today. He said he has forgiven them, though they didn't ask for it:
Because forgiving people makes things easier for you, not easier for the people. Um Yeah. Forgiveness is something that you're allowed to do selfishly. Um you're allowed to forgive people that have hurt you. Just understanding that we all make mistakes and we all err. Now that I'm older, I see how much pressure must have been on them and how easy it would be to make a bad decision.
I see how much pressure must have been on them. That's my whole argument, in his words. He forgave his parents and named the reason: they were under pressure. The Insight entry said the parent who doesn't use the rod brings "disgrace and God's disapproval to himself." That's pressure. And the elder in Japan, still inside, asked the same question I would:
Didn't the parents, torn inside, harden their hearts and follow it, telling themselves this is Jehovah's will?
Torn inside. They knew. They all know what's right. That's the problem.
So no, the religion of Jehovah's Witnesses didn't condone what happened to Katt Williams. But a religion doesn't have to condone something to build the conditions where it happens and nobody stops it. Children are taught to fear the people who could help them. Parents are told the rod is their duty before God. The congregation watches the performance and applauds. Elders get a phone number for the lawyers. Everyone else is told not to read anything negative.
If you're still a Jehovah's Witness, you already know the right answer, because Watchtower printed it: the abuser brings reproach on God's name, not the person who calls for help. Your own elders' manual says victims are free to report. If a child is being hurt, call the authorities. Don't let the machine talk you out of what you already know.
The administrators at Katt Williams's school didn't need a manual to know what they were looking at. Neither do you.
This article is a written companion to the video above from the ExJW Analyzer YouTube channel. Watch the full video, or explore the research wiki for sourced, primary-document analysis.
← More video breakdowns