Jehovah's Witness Congregations Are Disappearing - Here's Why

Since 2015, more than 2,000 Jehovah's Witness congregations in the United States alone have disappeared. Watchtower says that's just good management. But its own internal rule book for closing a congregation lists a second reason, one you will never hear from the platform of a Kingdom Hall.

Below are that rule book, Watchtower's own congregation numbers, and what people sitting in those Kingdom Halls say about what is happening around them.

Watchtower's Rule Book for Closing a Congregation

The document is called Instructions for Merging Congregations, Form S67. In the 2022 edition, paragraph 2, under "factors to consider," it says that the dissolution of a congregation may be considered if there are an insufficient number of local publishers or elders to support the congregation, and if present publisher growth and potential for growth from the field are minimal.

So Watchtower is saying a congregation can be shut down if there aren't enough publishers, if there aren't enough elders, and if there is little hope of finding more of either.

Now compare that with what a 2017 US branch letter said when it announced that a congregation was being dissolved and its Kingdom Hall sold. The first sentence the congregation heard was this:

It is thrilling to see the rapid growth of the visible part of Jehovah's organization.

And when a 73-year-old elder who had built some of the furniture for his own Kingdom Hall watched it close, The Watchtower held up his story as an example of a test of loyalty.

So Watchtower claims rapid growth while it closes and sells Kingdom Halls and merges congregations. Which is it? Is Watchtower just tidying up its real estate, or is it running out of people?

I've noted before that US congregations dropped from about 14,000 to under 12,000. But I also said that the drop isn't necessarily proof of shrinking on its own. Congregations can merge for many reasons, and some of them have nothing to do with people leaving. So I set out to find out whether it really is evidence of shrinking.

Watchtower's instructions give only a few reasons to close a congregation: better use of a nearby hall, or not enough publishers or elders. My claim is that over the last decade or so, the second reason has overtaken the first. I was born and raised a Jehovah's Witness and stayed one until I was 40 years old. Here is the evidence.

The Official Numbers: 2,260 US Congregations Gone

Watchtower publishes the number of congregations in every country for every year. According to the 2016 Yearbook, the United States had 14,063 congregations in 2015. Watchtower's own service year report for 2025, which you can look up on jw.org right now, shows a count 2,260 congregations lower. That is down 16% over ten years.

It didn't happen in one big jump or one major sell-off. The count declined every single year. That's ten years, each one with a drop, and the steepest drops came between 2016 and 2019. In not one year did the number go back up.

Here is what makes this interesting. Over the same period, the number of publishers in the United States barely changed. In 2015 the peak was 1.2 million. In 2023 it was barely 2,000 more than that.

I stop at 2023 on purpose. That year Watchtower changed how it counts a publisher, so the numbers before and after aren't comparable, and the newer ones aren't very reliable. Up to that change, though, the number is flat.

So the same number of Jehovah's Witnesses ended up in fewer congregations, which means each congregation had to get bigger, at least on paper. In 2015 the average US congregation had about 88 publishers. By 2023 it was about 103.

Not Just the United States: The Western Decline

This isn't only happening in the United States. Compare 2025 with each country's own peak year:

  • Japan has lost a quarter of its congregations since 1998.
  • Sweden has also lost a quarter.
  • Switzerland and the Netherlands have lost more than a fifth.
  • Canada is down 18% since 2016.
  • France is down 16%, Italy 14%, and Germany 13%.

It isn't happening everywhere, though. Worldwide, the number of congregations is basically flat. It peaked at about 120,000 in 2020 and was just under that in 2025. That's a small drop, not a collapse, because in parts of Africa and Latin America Watchtower really is growing, and growing fairly fast.

So this isn't a story about Jehovah's Witnesses vanishing everywhere. It's a story about what is happening in Western nations. Watchtower's official counts show that in the United States and across much of the West, it is running fewer, bigger congregations, and has done so every year for a decade.

The numbers alone don't explain why. Fewer congregations with the same number of people could simply be a choice made for efficiency, or it could be an early sign of something much worse. To find out which, the next piece of evidence is Watchtower saying, in its own words, what it looks for when it decides to close a congregation.

Two Reasons to Close a Congregation: A People Problem and a Building Problem

When a circuit overseer believes a congregation should be dissolved, he follows Form S67. I've examined four editions of it: 2011, 2017, 2019, and 2022. The grounds for dissolving a congregation are the same in every one, and there are two of them.

The first one appears above: an insufficient number of local publishers or elders to support the congregation, together with minimal growth. The second is in the next sentence. A congregation can also be dissolved if this would result in better use of a nearby Kingdom Hall.

So Watchtower gives basically two reasons to shut down a congregation. One is a people problem and the other is a building problem. The only one you'll hear about from the platform is the building problem. Watchtower doesn't talk about its shrinking in the West.

What the Elders Manual Says About Mergers

The current, 2025 edition of Shepherd the Flock of God, the Jehovah's Witness elders manual, says in chapter 13 that the branch decides whether congregations need to be merged. It lists benefits of doing so: better use of existing Kingdom Halls, better distribution of experienced brothers, and an improved quality of meetings.

Think about what those benefits mean.

  • Better use of existing Kingdom Halls means they have more seats than people. As you'll see below, that is exactly how the branch measures it.
  • An improved quality of meetings means there weren't enough brothers to handle the parts.
  • Better distribution of experienced brothers means there weren't enough qualified men to go around, so you pull two congregations together into one.

I've discussed elsewhere that Watchtower has a severe shortage of men to take the lead in the congregations. Two of those three benefits are about people, and the one about buildings is about filling the halls they already have.

The 2023 edition of the elders manual added a fourth benefit: a reduction in the number of Kingdom Halls needing to be constructed. That one is gone from the 2025 manual. They aren't talking about building anymore.

Quietly Dropped: "Improved Meeting Attendance"

Form S67 echoes much of this. The 2011 edition says that many congregations that have merged have experienced improved meeting attendance, higher-quality meetings, and a better distribution of experienced brothers. The 2017 edition drops the part about higher meeting attendance but keeps the parts about quality and the distribution of brothers.

I find that dropped phrase interesting. The elders manual kept it for a while. The 2023 edition still lists improved meeting attendance as a benefit, but by the 2025 edition it's gone there too. I don't know why they cut it, because neither document says. I'm just showing you that it's gone.

Widening the Net: Less Protection for Small Congregations

Two other edits since 2011 point the same way: Watchtower is widening the range of congregations it might dissolve.

Small rural congregations used to be safe. The form said they "do not need to be dissolved." Now it says they "may not need to be dissolved."

Local elders also used to have to be in agreement with the recommendation. Now the circuit overseer simply notes whether they have serious reservations.

So small rural congregations have less protection now, and the elders who run them have less say.

Kept Confidential, and the Money Stays With the Branch

The form also explains how the congregation is told. The circuit overseer's recommendation should remain confidential and should not be shared with the publishers in the congregations. The congregation finds out at the next midweek meeting, once the decision is official.

Here is the part that should upset you. According to the form, the money the congregation put into the Kingdom Hall operating fund would not be returned to the congregation. Watchtower keeps it. And the last line of the 2022 form says this:

If the Kingdom Hall will be sold, the branch office will provide further instruction.

Nobody asks the publishers who paid to build that Kingdom Hall, who did the physical work of building it, whether they want their congregation dissolved. They don't get their money back. They are simply told by Watchtower that the congregation is being dissolved. The money stays with the branch, the building goes to the branch, and if or when it's sold, the branch gets the proceeds.

So by Watchtower's own criteria, a merger can be a sign that a congregation is running short of people, or short of elders and other men to run it. But the rule book only tells you when they're allowed to close a congregation. It doesn't tell you which reason they used. For that, you have to look at what they told members while it was happening, and that is where the language gets strange.

The 2014–2019 Policy Wave: "Growth" While Selling Halls

The policy wave ran roughly from 2014 to 2019.

On October 31, 2014, the branch in Britain wrote to every congregation about new arrangements for building and renovating Kingdom Halls. The letter opens:

In order to support global expansion, more efficient use needs to be made of Kingdom Halls and Assembly Halls.

Then it says:

It is possible that Kingdom Halls can be used by four congregations.

And it says the branch office has been directed to consider whether meeting places should be consolidated so that underutilized Kingdom Halls can be sold. The very next line says:

The advancement of Jehovah's organization is clear for us to see.

Just as in the letter quoted at the top, they tie the consolidation of congregations and the sale of buildings to growth and expansion, as if the two had anything to do with each other.

In the United States, a letter to the elders dated February 23, 2015, says that decisions about which congregations should use a Kingdom Hall are now made by the branch office, not the local elders. The elders have nothing to do with it anymore. Only the branch decides.

Measuring Attendance Against Seats

Another 2015 letter to the elders, dated July 8 and titled "Fully Utilizing Kingdom Hall Auditoriums," told elders that the January broadcast had explained the urgent need for Kingdom Halls throughout the United States.

An urgent need for Kingdom Halls. Keep that in mind, because of what the same letter goes on to say. It says that congregation meeting attendance is compared with auditorium capacity, and if the hall isn't full enough, the branch office may decide that a new Kingdom Hall is not needed and direct that a merger take place. "Such adjustments will result in conserving donated funds."

Once again, the elders are told there is an urgent need for Kingdom Halls while also being warned that mergers are coming.

Put simply, in 2015 Watchtower decided to check every Kingdom Hall's attendance against the number of seats in the auditorium, and if there weren't enough people in those seats, to merge the congregations with others.

The Template Letter, and the Postscript Members Never See

Here is how Watchtower presented this to the people it affected. A letter from the United States branch dated March 6, 2017, was sent to two congregations in Salsbury, North Carolina. These letters are built from a template. They aren't custom-written for each congregation, and they are read to congregations whose hall is about to be taken from them and, as shown above, handed to the branch.

The first sentence is the one quoted at the start:

It is thrilling to see the rapid growth of the visible part of Jehovah's organization. This has increased the need to provide adequate places of worship.

So they say they're experiencing rapid growth and need adequate places of worship. Yet in the same letter the congregation's Kingdom Hall is being taken, the branch gets the money, and any money the congregation gave the branch to hold isn't going back to it.

The letter then explains that the branch compared congregation meeting attendance with total seating capacity and that "adjustments involving your congregations will soon take place." That's what the congregation gets, and the instructions say to post it on the information board.

The elders, however, get a postscript the rank and file aren't supposed to see. The letter says:

However, this postscript should neither be read to the congregation nor posted on the information board.

And it's in the postscript that the actual decision appears: merge the congregation into others nearby and sell the Kingdom Hall at the listed street address. The letter on the information board talks about growth. The sale of the Kingdom Hall is the part the congregation, the people most affected by the decision, isn't allowed to see.

This wasn't one overenthusiastic letter writer, either. The bottom of the first page identifies it as a template letter used by the Service Department for mergers and dissolutions that came from a branch recommendation or other branch initiative. That's the Service Department's standard wording. Closures started by the branch got this opening.

The instructions that came with it are just as troubling. When the branch itself initiated the dissolution, "there will be no need for the local elders to sign the letter of recommendation." Again, they have no say at all. And the legal cost of signing the Kingdom Hall over to Watchtower "should not exceed $1,000" and "should be paid out of the operating account of the dissolving congregation."

So the congregation Watchtower has decided to shut down, with or without its approval, pays for the legal paperwork that hands its hall over to Watchtower.

The same thing was happening in other countries. In January 2017, the branch in Spain wrote that the branch had merged congregations, transferred congregations, and closed some underutilized halls. It then thanked the elders for supporting decisions that are "not always easy to understand." But how would anyone know they supported those decisions? They had no say in whether their Kingdom Hall was closed or sold.

You can see this wave in what people were posting on ex-JW Reddit at the time. Discussion of mergers and hall sales peaked from 2018 through 2022, which overlaps the years when the US congregation count was falling fastest. Between 2016 and 2019, the United States lost about 480 congregations a year.

Attendance, Not Publishers, Decides Whether a Hall Stays Open

Look at what the branch actually measured in those letters. It didn't measure how many publishers were on the books. It measured how many people were showing up. Congregation meeting attendance is compared with auditorium capacity.

The publisher total is the number Watchtower publishes openly. But the number it actually uses to decide whether your Kingdom Hall stays open is how many people are in the seats. That raises a question: how accurate is the publisher count, if it isn't what they use to decide whether a Kingdom Hall gets closed and sold?

To be fair, repacking half-full Kingdom Halls doesn't require anyone to leave. Put two half-full congregations together and you get a full one. So the first big wave of closures really does qualify as a top-down real estate program. What makes it damning is how it was handled: members were told about growth, while the sale was kept in the part they weren't allowed to see.

But repacking halls should be a one-time job. Once the Kingdom Halls are full, closures should slow way down. So the real test is what happened after the sell-off. That's when the reports from inside the halls start to change.

What Members Report From Inside the Halls

To find out what was happening inside the halls, I analyzed every ex-JW Reddit post and comment in which someone described their congregation shrinking or getting older. There were close to 900. I counted only people describing their own hall, as a share of everything posted on the subreddit that year.

Here's what changed. Reports of a shrinking congregation roughly doubled from 2023 on, and they've stayed at that level. Reports of a mostly elderly hall held steady for ten years, then doubled in 2026. That's a dozen or two people a year reporting on it. It isn't a measurement of the halls themselves, but listen to what they're saying.

In August 2023, one user wrote about a father, still in the organization, who noticed the numbers falling. At the last meeting, about 40 seats were filled on the first night of the circuit overseer's visit. The father said there used to be about 150 people. If you know anything about circuit overseer visits, that's the week of the year everyone makes an effort to attend, and attendance was down to a third or less of what it had been.

A year later, another user went back to a meeting after a year away:

Normally, attendance was 110 to 120 people two years ago. This meeting was the circuit overseer. Attendance was 79 people.

Again, poor attendance at the one time most people make an effort to show up.

Here's a big one from 2024:

Now, after CO, three congregations of 300 publishers have shrunk to around 60 to 70 active at the meetings.

One from January 2026, from New Jersey:

We went from seven thriving congregations to four that now average only 50 to 70 attendees.

From June 2026:

Where my parents still attend has merged three times with other congregations because they keep shrinking.

Three mergers, and it still isn't enough. They're still shrinking.

Another from January, this time a Spanish congregation in southern Los Angeles:

Just in my meeting where it was announced that on April 1st, our congregation will be dissolved and we will all be sent to different congregations.

An Aging Membership: "There's No Kids Left"

Those are a few of the posts about shrinking. Others are about age. Among all the posts I pulled, 34 gave an actual average age for their own Kingdom Hall. Of those, 24 put their congregation somewhere between 60 and 75, and all but two said 50 or older.

Most of those are eyeball estimates, and I won't pretend they're precise. But look at how tightly they cluster. From October 2026:

Average age of my congregation is 73.

From the UK in 2021:

My hall, for instance, has 70% of people over 50. The average age is 64.

And one person put it best:

The youngest publisher in my congregation now is old enough to drink. There's no kids left.

It isn't happening everywhere. Some people write that their halls are as packed as they were before COVID. But when you look at where those posts come from, they're mostly areas that many people are moving into, such as Florida, the Carolinas, and Arizona, with new housing developments. A growing town can hide a shrinking religion for a long time.

Those posts were the minority, though, and they aren't increasing. The shrinking posts were the ones that increased, and the elderly posts held steady for a long time.

Census Data: Jehovah's Witnesses Are Aging Faster Than Everyone Else

We don't have to rely only on what members say. Watchtower doesn't publish the ages of its members, but several governments ask about religion in their census and publish the ages. These figures cover people who tell the census they are Jehovah's Witnesses.

To be fair, that's a wider group than Watchtower counts. Some people call themselves Jehovah's Witnesses even if they're no longer counted, and the group includes children and people who no longer go out in service. But the data is independent, and it's the same question asked the same way every time.

Australia

Of all the countries that collect this, Australia has the best data. In 2001, Witnesses were actually slightly younger than Australians overall: about 12% were over 65, against about 13% of the country. By 2021, almost a quarter of Witnesses were over 65, against one in six Australians.

In 2001, Witness children under 15 outnumbered Witnesses over 65. By 2021 that had flipped. There were almost two retirees for every Witness child. The total barely moved the whole time, from about 81,000 to 84,000. Same number of Witnesses, just much older.

New Zealand

New Zealand publishes the median age of each religion. In ten years, the median age of Witnesses rose four and a half years, to almost 46. The country as a whole barely moved, but the Witnesses are aging.

Canada

In 2001, Witnesses in Canada were about the same age as other Canadians. By 2021, more than one in four Witnesses was over 65, against fewer than one in five Canadians generally. The number of people calling themselves Jehovah's Witnesses also fell, by about 17,000.

Ireland

In Ireland, the share of Witnesses over 65 more than doubled in eleven years.

The United States and the Pew Data

Pew's large religion survey found that Jehovah's Witnesses over 65 went from 14% in 2007 to 23% in 2014, older than Catholics and evangelicals. That's a survey, so you have to allow a few points of error either way.

Pew also measured something in 2016 that fits the picture. Among all US adults raised as Jehovah's Witnesses, two-thirds no longer identify with the group. Two out of three children raised as Witnesses don't stay. They leave when they become adults.

Pew didn't connect those two numbers, but the link isn't hard to see. A religion that loses two-thirds of its children is going to get dramatically older.

What the Data Shows

Here's what all of this tells us. Where the data goes back to 2001, in Australia and Canada, Jehovah's Witnesses were about the same age as everyone else. Since then, in every country where I can find the data, they've aged faster than the people around them, with fewer children and far more people over 65.

That's four governments and a Pew survey, none of them from Watchtower and none from Reddit, so they're more objective. Ex-JW Reddit tends to be less objective, but all of them show the same thing. The story members tell has shifted from "they sold our hall" to "there's nobody left here; it's shrinking." And the aging they describe shows up independently in four national censuses and a Pew survey.

That brings us back to the rule book, because it names two separate shortages that can justify closing a congregation. We've looked at publishers and how they're shrinking in many places. The second shortage is elders, and it reaches a long way up the organization.

The Shortage of Elders

The benefit the elders manual promises from merging congregations is better distribution of experienced brothers. You don't need to redistribute something you have plenty of.

Watchtower doesn't publish the ages of its elders any more than it publishes the ages of the rank and file. However, I recently received a piece of information. It comes from a single source, and I haven't found a second one yet. According to one PIMO elder who reached out after attending a recent elder school, figures shown there put about 3% of elders in North America under 30 years old. If you attended the same school, I'd welcome the information so I can verify it.

That matches what members describe again and again: elders in their 60s and 70s, and nobody younger stepping up to take over. Here's what one man who serves as an elder recently wrote on ex-JW Reddit:

I used to run the numbers on the age demographics of the congregation. I pointed out that we were in trouble and should make a concerted effort to engage young people more. My fellow elders looked at me like I was a kook.

His congregation is facing closure now, he said, because of its aging body of elders and publishers.

And from September:

Most attendants in my congregation are in their 40s to 70s, and they have been getting 12-year-old kids and teens to do the mics, and the Kingdom Hall is filled with mostly elderly people.

Lowered Appointment Ages and Elders Stepping Down

I've covered Watchtower's reaction to this before. It has set the age for appointing elders at 21 and ministerial servants at 18. My entire time in the religion, elders were rarely appointed before 30, usually in their upper 30s, and servants had to be 19. And in a leaked video, Mark Sanderson said that a circuit overseer can be appointed at just 25.

Since September 2026, elders have also been publicly stepping down at a rate I've never seen before.

Now Whole Circuits Are Being Dissolved

Move up a level to the circuit, a group of roughly 20 congregations managed by one circuit overseer.

On December 4, 2017, the branch wrote to all congregations in Britain and Ireland about changes to the circuits:

Due to the increase we have witnessed over the past few years, a number of circuits have grown…

Circuits growing, it said, in 2017. But in March 2025, one person posted that, according to an announcement at their meeting, the circuits in Britain would be decreasing by five.

Watchtower doesn't publish an official circuit count, so I couldn't confirm that number from anything it prints. But that person isn't alone. On ex-JW Reddit, people describing their own circuit being dissolved went from a handful a year up to 2022 to 15 or more every year since 2023. In March 2026, one person wrote:

Our circuit is being dissolved. I asked two elders why and basically didn't get much of an answer. They explained it like it's some restructuring thing.

So it isn't just congregations being folded or merged anymore. It's circuits too. And it isn't just members who are missing. It's also the men Watchtower needs to run what's left.

Watchtower's Best Defense, and Why It Fails

Here is the strongest case for Watchtower's side. Consolidation is good stewardship. Watchtower had too many half-empty buildings, so it put more congregations in each one, sold the rest, and saved donated money. Nobody left. The US publisher count held steady through 2023. People simply regrouped into bigger, healthier congregations. Worldwide, the number of congregations is basically flat, and parts of the world are growing. So where's the decline?

Some of that is true, and I'll concede it. The big drop between 2016 and 2019 was largely policy, as those letters show, and the US publisher numbers really did hold through 2023. If the evidence ended with the policy letters, that defense would have a good argument. But it doesn't survive the rest of the evidence.

First: The Closures Never Stopped

If this were only about filling Kingdom Halls, the count would have leveled off once the halls were full. The fastest drops came from 2016 to 2019, and they've slowed since, but they've never stopped. The count fell in 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025, years after those sell-off letters. Those are the same years members started reporting thinner and thinner meetings at twice the old rate.

Part of that is Zoom. Since COVID, many publishers stay home and log in, a lot of them with cameras off, according to reports. That creates empty seats without anyone leaving Watchtower's publisher count. But notice what that argument concedes: people who used to come to the hall don't anymore. And Zoom can't explain the rest. It doesn't make the census population older, and it doesn't make the elders older.

Second: It Doesn't Explain the Missing Men

The rule book has said since 2011 that a lack of publishers or elders could lead to closures, so the wording alone can't tell you what is driving closures now. What it does tell you comes from everything that has happened around it. Watchtower lowered the appointment ages to 21 and 18, and to 25 for a circuit overseer. Members describe aging bodies of elders and kids running the microphones. One elder says his congregation is facing closure because of its aging body of elders and publishers. And circuits are reportedly being cut in Britain, where members were told in 2017 that circuits were growing.

An organization with too many buildings sells the buildings. It doesn't go looking for 21-year-old elders and 25-year-old circuit overseers.

Third: It Doesn't Explain the Census

A building program can't make Australian Witnesses older. It can't flip the ratio of children to retirees. Something else is doing that, and it's the same thing members and Pew Research describe: young people aren't staying, and the people who remain are getting older. Watchtower can change what counts as a publisher, but it can't change what people tell the national census.

A Test of Loyalty: How Watchtower Frames a Closing Kingdom Hall

All of this brings us back to the elder mentioned at the start. His story is what lands this whole thing. If this were just good management, why does Watchtower treat it as a test of whether you'll stay loyal?

Look at how it prepares its own members. The Watchtower of November 2022, study article 48, is titled "Keep Your Senses When Your Loyalty Is Tested." It covers three challenges that can arise within the congregation: feeling mistreated by a fellow Christian, receiving discipline, and organizational changes. The example it uses for organizational changes is a congregation merger.

Before it gets there, it warns:

Organizational changes can test our loyalty. If we are not careful, we could even allow them to separate us from Jehovah.

Then it brings up Korah, who challenged the authority of Moses and Aaron.

It then tells the story of a 73-year-old elder in Slovenia whose congregation was merged with another and whose Kingdom Hall was closed. He says:

I did not understand why such a beautiful Kingdom Hall would be closed … I am a carpenter, and I had built some of the new furniture … the reorganization required many adjustments that were not easy for us older publishers.

The answer the article gives him isn't an explanation. It's a promise:

When you support such changes and loyally stick to Jehovah and the organization that he is using, you will surely be blessed.

The elder himself adds a line that should get every Witness's attention:

These refinements are preparing us for even greater changes in the future.

Watchtower has been dropping lines like that frequently lately, so more is clearly coming.

Here's why it matters. When the organization files a closing Kingdom Hall right next to being disciplined and calls it a test of your loyalty, it's telling you how to feel before you've had a chance to ask what it means. If a closed Kingdom Hall and a longer drive to another one are a test of your loyalty, then wondering whether it's a sign of decline is a test of loyalty too, and thinking about it means you're being disloyal.

And notice who the article's example is: a 73-year-old elder describing what it was like for "us older publishers." That fits, because older people, not younger ones, are increasingly who the census shows remaining.

The Takeaway: A People Problem in the West

For the United States and much of the Western world, it's more likely than not that Watchtower is closing and merging congregations because it has a people problem: emptier seats, older members, and not enough younger men to run things. That is the shortage its own form describes.

The first wave was a building program that members were told represented growth. The second wave is a shortage of people. The remaining halls are getting older and meeting attendance is getting thinner. Members and one insider describe aging bodies of elders with nobody behind them to take over, and now whole circuits are being folded.

Watchtower's own numbers, its own paperwork, four national censuses, a Pew survey, and ten years of reports from members and insiders all point the same way. That doesn't mean a worldwide collapse, at least not yet. The global count is flat, and there is real growth in parts of Africa. But it doesn't bode well for the organization in Western countries. And in some of those African nations, the growth is below the general population growth, so the organization is still falling behind.

If you're a Jehovah's Witness and a Kingdom Hall near you closed in the last couple of years, and you were told it was about making better use of the building, you now know there's a form for that, a confidential one you weren't supposed to see. You know the decision was made by the branch and your elders had nothing to do with it. You know Watchtower gets the money from the sale, along with any money your congregation gave the branch to hold. You know a shortage of publishers and elders is one of the reasons Watchtower lists for shutting down congregations. And if you start wondering what that says about the organization, Watchtower has already told you that's a test of your loyalty, and that the way to pass is not to ask.

This article is a written companion to the video above from the ExJW Analyzer YouTube channel. Watch the full video, or explore the research wiki for sourced, primary-document analysis.

← More video breakdowns