Is the Watchtower Using the Same Playbook as Jonestown?
On the Watchtower's official broadcast, Jonathan Smith stood up and told millions of Jehovah's Witnesses to be ready to obey the organization even when its instructions seem to put them in danger:
Or what if instructions from Jehovah's organization seem to put us in danger? As when Israel appeared to be trapped at the Red Sea.
That is the most disturbing statement to Jehovah's Witnesses that I've heard in 20 years. Smith used the Red Sea as his model: Israel trapped against the water with an army at their backs. The lesson was that when the direction looks dangerous, you obey anyway. The word dangerous is new. I went back through 60 years of Watchtower publications to be sure. For two decades this exact teaching has been escalating one word at a time, and it never reached dangerous until now. If the language has finally reached dangerous, the question that matters is this: what's the next rung above that?
I was a baptized Jehovah's Witness all of my life, and I sat through hundreds of these talks. I know the difference between ordinary trust-God encouragement and something with a harder edge underneath it. For this one I didn't go on memory. Every Watchtower quoted below is identified by date so you can check it yourself. I'll lay out the talk fairly first. Then I'll show the same instruction as the Watchtower has written it over 20 years, in order, so you can watch the language escalate. Then I'll show the same pattern in other groups, groups whose names you know for terrible reasons. Millions of people are being prepared right now, in their weekly meetings, to do something on command that they haven't been told yet. It's worth knowing what they're being prepared for.
A Morning Worship Talk About Faithfulness in "What Is Least"
The only honest way to do this is to be fair to the talk first. It's a morning worship talk called "Faithfully Obey in What Is Least." It's built on Luke 16:10: the person faithful in what is least is faithful also in much. On its face the message is humble, and it might sound reasonable. Be reliable in small things and you'll be reliable in big ones. The speaker walks through Exodus, Moses, the plagues, the Passover and the Red Sea, and draws out a theme of trusting God when his instructions are hard to understand.
If you stopped there, you'd think it was just a sermon about faith. Lots of religions preach trust in God during difficult times. But one detail doesn't fit a sermon about trusting God, and it comes right at the opening:
Well, our scripture text for today, along with the Watch Tower comments, uh indicate that our obedience in small matters may actually affect our survival during the coming great tribulation.
Our obedience in small matters may affect our survival. That's not a line about being a dependable person. It's a line about staying alive. Once survival enters the picture, this stops being a sermon and becomes something you need to read very carefully, because the talk goes on to stack up quote after quote from recent Watchtowers to make its case. The talk frames obedience as a survival skill. Hold on to that word, survival, because every rung on the ladder below is tied to it.
2007: "Keeping in Step"
It starts in 2007, with the Watchtower telling members what the great tribulation will require of them:
We may well receive some detailed instructions. Our safe journey through those troublesome days will depend on keeping in step with other loyal servants of Jehovah.
Your safe journey, meaning your survival, will depend on keeping in step. Already in 2007, obedience and survival are welded together. But there's no edge to it yet. "Keep in step" might sound like marching in a parade. Nobody reads that sentence and gets nervous.
2012: "Saved Only If We Obey"
In 2012 the language takes its first hard step. The simplified edition of the April Watchtower is written in plain language for the members with the least education: the newest and the youngest. In that edition the wording is blunt:
Christians will need to obey instructions from God's word and organization. We will be saved only if we obey the instructions we receive at that time.
There's a detail here worth pausing on. The regular study edition of that same article was softer. It said only that our deliverance will depend on obedience. The simplified edition, the one handed to the people least equipped to push back, is the one that spells it out: saved only if you obey. The plainer the audience, the plainer the threat.
So by 2012 the teaching is fully formed. You will be saved only if you obey instructions you haven't been given yet. Everything after this is the Watchtower slowly answering one question: what if those instructions feel wrong?
That question should stop you. Once you've told somebody their survival depends on obeying future instructions, the obvious human objection is, what if the instruction is a mistake? What if it's senseless? What if it's dangerous? A healthy organization would welcome that question. Watch instead how the Watchtower spends the next 12 years shutting it down, adjective by adjective.
This is the part that hits differently when you've lived inside it. I remember being taught to feel proud of my own obedience and to treat hesitation as a flaw in me, never a flaw in the instruction. That feeling has a long runway behind it.
2013: Obey Whether It "Appears Sound" or Not
In 2013 the Watchtower took its first swing at that objection. The instruction might not look right, and that doesn't matter:
All of us must be ready to obey any instructions we may receive, whether these appear sound from a strategic or human standpoint or not.
That's the first rung above keeping in step. Now the instruction might not appear sound. It might look wrong strategically or humanly, and you need to obey it anyway. For Jehovah's Witnesses, the door marked "But this doesn't look right" was nailed shut.
2021: Direction That "Does Not Make Sense to Us"
The 2021 article goes further and gets more specific about who is giving the orders:
At times, those appointed to take the lead may give direction that does not make sense to us. However, Jehovah blesses obedience.
Look how far things moved in 14 years. In 2007 it was keeping in step. Now the men giving direction may give direction that doesn't make sense, and your job is to obey it anyway because Jehovah blesses obedience. The instruction no longer has to be sound. It no longer has to make sense.
Isn't This Just Normal Religious Faith?
That's the fair pushback: isn't this just trusting God when you don't understand? There was a time I would have answered it that way too, so let me give it its strongest form. Yes, lots of faiths teach trusting God through confusion and difficult times. But the next two rungs are where this stops being about trusting God and becomes about trusting men.
2022: Instructions for a Danger You Think Is Unlikely
The March 2022 study article spells out the kinds of instructions to expect:
At times this slave may give direction that we do not fully understand. For example, we may receive specific instructions designed to prepare us to survive a natural disaster that we think is unlikely to occur in our area. Or we may feel that the slave is being overly cautious during a pandemic. What should we do if we feel that the instructions given are not practical?
Obey detailed survival instructions even for a danger you have good reason to believe isn't real or is unlikely to occur where you live.
Then the December 2022 study article, the one Witnesses discussed in early 2023, removes the last condition:
Do your best to obey the direction you receive even if you do not fully understand why it is being given.
There's no qualifier left. It's no longer "if it seems unsound" or "if it doesn't make sense." Now you obey even if you have no idea why. Every off-ramp a thinking person would reach for has been closed, one article at a time.
"Never Reveal Information" to Those Not Entitled to It
That same article says something else:
Also, never reveal information about our brothers and sisters or about congregation activities to those who are not entitled to it.
Who exactly is the Watchtower talking about? Who do they think isn't entitled to this information? The police? The courts? They don't say. But the very next paragraph says that Satan wages war against God's people. And who does the Watchtower teach rules the governments of the world, including the police, the courts and the authorities? They teach that Satan rules them.
Have Watchtower's representatives misled courts before? Philip Brumley was sanctioned for misleading statements and had to pay a $150,000 fine, a fine that was upheld on appeal. So I'll ask again: in what they call a time of crisis that is part of Satan's war against them, who is the Watchtower saying Jehovah's Witnesses shouldn't give information to? I don't know. They don't say. I'll leave that for you to decide.
Between 2013 and 2022, the Watchtower walked the instruction from might not appear sound, to might not make sense, to might address a danger that isn't real, to you don't have to understand it at all. That isn't my characterization. It's their own sentences, in order.
2023: COVID-19 as a Rehearsal
Then, in late 2023, they did something that gives the whole thing away:
For example, during the early part of the COVID-19 pandemic, when we were asked to stop meeting at our Kingdom Halls and to suspend our house-to-house ministry, did you struggle to obey? Yet, your obedience protected you, united you with fellow believers, and pleased Jehovah. All of us are now better prepared to obey any instructions we received during the Great Tribulation. Our lives may depend on it.
During COVID, the organization told Witnesses to stop meeting and stop the door-to-door work. Looking back, the 2023 Watchtower says that obedience means "all of us are now better prepared to obey any instructions we receive during the Great Tribulation."
That sentence is a tell. They are openly calling a past obedience event a rehearsal. COVID wasn't just handled; it was practiced. It made members better prepared to obey the next thing. And the article doesn't leave the stakes to your imagination. The very next sentence is six words long: Our lives may depend on it.
That's the moment this stops looking like a religion teaching patience and starts looking like a system running drills. If you were a Witness during the COVID shutdown, ask yourself whether you experienced it as a test of obedience. Reading this article, that's exactly what the organization now says it was.
2024: "Conveyed by Imperfect Men"
So survival has been tied to obedience. Every reason you might resist has been removed. A rehearsal has been run. Only one rung is left. The February 2024 study article adds who you're really obeying:
We might occasionally find it a challenge to follow Jehovah's guidance, especially when it is conveyed by imperfect men. Why? The counsel may conflict with our likes or dislikes, or we might feel that the direction we receive is unwise and conclude that the counsel must not be from Jehovah.
Conveyed by imperfect men. They said it themselves: the direction comes through fallible humans. In 2017 the Governing Body admitted that they are neither inspired nor infallible and that they can err in doctrinal matters or in organizational direction. When fallible men who admit they make mistakes give you orders that sound unwise, you would naturally feel that this can't be from God, that it isn't right. The article names that exact feeling so it can be labeled a failure. Your own conscience and your own internal alarm bells are reframed as a problem you need to overcome.
2026: Instructions That "Seem to Put Us in Danger"
That brings us back to the talk. After keeping in step, may not appear sound, does not make sense, you don't have to understand, and even if it comes from imperfect men who make mistakes, here's the new rung in the speaker's own words:
What if we receive instructions from Jehovah's organization that at first seem ineffective? Maybe these instructions seem to make our life even harder, as when Israel had to find straw in addition to making bricks. Or what if the instructions we receive seem overly intrusive into our personal lives, personal decisions, such as what we eat, how to cook it, and even how we eat it? Or what if we don't understand the reasons for certain instructions for days or weeks or months or even another 1,500 years? Or what if instructions from Jehovah's organization seem to put us in danger, as when Israel appeared to be trapped at the Red Sea?
What if instructions from Jehovah's organization seem to put us in danger? That's a frightening question to put to millions of people.
I searched the entire body of Watchtower literature, six decades of it. You don't have to take my word for this, because that whole library is free and searchable on the Watchtower's own website. Run the search yourself. In the context of obeying the organization, the words "dangerous," "put us in danger" or "place us in danger" have never appeared before. They show up in old magazines about things like car accidents and household chemicals, but never about obeying direction from the organization. This is the first time the Watchtower has ever reached for the word danger as the example of an instruction you should still obey.
A brand-new rung has been added to the ladder of obedience. You're supposed to obey even if it seems unsound, even if it makes no sense, even if you don't understand it, even when it comes from imperfect men who admit they make mistakes, and now even if it looks like it could get you hurt.
Am I Cherry-Picking?
Did I comb 60 years of magazines and string together the scariest sentences I could find? I have two honest answers.
First, I didn't have to hunt for most of these. The talk stacked them itself. The speaker lined up 2007, 2012, 2022, 2023 and 2024 as proof of how consistent the message has been:
Note, however, other similar comments from Watchtowers over the years. For example, December 2007 says, "As we get nearer to the outbreak of the Great Tribulation, we may well receive some detailed instructions. Our safe journey through those troublesome days will depend on our keeping in step with other loyal servants of Jehovah. April 2012 Watchtower. During the Great Tribulation Christians will need to obey instructions from God's word and organization. We will be saved only if we obey the instructions we receive at that time. March 2022 At times the slave may give direction that we do not fully understand. For example, we may receive specific instructions for surviving a natural disaster that we think is unlikely to occur in our area. October 2023 Watchtower During the early part of the COVID-19 pandemic when we were asked to stop meeting at our Kingdom Halls and to suspend our house-to-house ministry, did you struggle to obey? Yet your obedience protected you, united you with your fellow believers, and pleased Jehovah. All of us are now better prepared to obey any instructions we receive during the Great Tribulation. And finally Watchtower February of 2024 We might occasionally find it a challenge to follow Jehovah's guidance, especially when it is conveyed by imperfect men. Why? The counsel may conflict with our likes or dislikes. Or we might feel that the direction is unwise and that the counsel must not be from Jehovah. So as we can see the Watchtower in recent years has repeatedly reminded us to obey, even though, as today's Watchtower comments indicate, we may receive instructions that seem strange, impractical, or even illogical.
Smith is right that the message has been consistent. Second, the one claim I'm making on my own, that dangerous is new, I didn't test against a handful of articles. I tested it against the entire library. Every other rung on this ladder is the organization quoting itself. I didn't go looking for this pattern. They're proud of it, and the speaker says so.
Foot-in-the-Door: Training Obedience in "What Is Least"
How does a person get to the point where "obey even when it's dangerous" sounds reasonable? To anyone outside, it wouldn't sound reasonable at all. It isn't done in one sermon. It's done the way the talk's own title describes.
The talk is built on Luke 16:10: be faithful in what is least, be obedient in little things. That is exactly a psychological technique called foot-in-the-door. You start with a tiny, harmless request to build the habit of saying yes, then you escalate, because each small act of compliance makes the next, larger one feel consistent. "Faithful in what is least" isn't a throwaway scripture here. It's the training method, named out loud. Practice obeying the small stuff, like what you wear and how you spend a Saturday, so that obedience is automatic when the big instructions come. The speaker says it plainly:
Now's the time to train ourselves to trust Jehovah, trust those whom he is using, and faithfully obey, even in little things.
The psychiatrist Robert J. Lifton studied how totalitarian systems remake the mind. He studied thought reform and described how the change happens incrementally, one step at a time, without being plainly visible to the person it's happening to. That's exactly what we just watched on the page. No single Watchtower article is alarming. "Keep in step" isn't particularly scary. "Does not make sense to us" might not seem scary either, though to me it kind of is. Each rung is small enough that you feel paranoid objecting to it. That isn't a flaw in the method. It's the whole reason it works. The danger was never in any one step. It's in the whole staircase. Train obedience on the things that are least, escalate one small step at a time, and the person never sees the staircase, only the next step.
Jonestown, Heaven's Gate and the Order of the Solar Temple
Everything so far is the Watchtower's own paper trail. Now I want to show where this same staircase has led in other groups, because that answers the question we started with: what comes after dangerous?
I want to be careful here, because this is where it would be easy to be irresponsible. I am not saying Jehovah's Witnesses are about to do what these other groups did. I'm saying the mechanism is identical, and the mechanism is what matters. Every group that ended in catastrophe got there by climbing a staircase that looked reasonable from each step.
Take Jonestown. Before the day everyone knows about, Jim Jones ran what he called "white nights" drills in his community. He called everyone together, told them they were under attack, and had them rehearse their response. On at least two occasions the rehearsal was a practice mass suicide. Members lined up, drank a liquid they were told was poison, and waited to die. Afterward they were told it had been a loyalty test. Researchers who studied this concluded that each repetition "prepared members first to accept and then commit even more extreme acts." The horror at the end wasn't a single decision. It was the last rung of a ladder of rehearsed obedience.
Now set that beside a Watchtower article calling the COVID shutdown practice that left members "better prepared to obey any instructions we received during the Great Tribulation." I'm not equating the content. I'm pointing at the structure. Rehearsing obedience so the real thing comes easier is the same move.
Then there are Heaven's Gate and the Order of the Solar Temple. The labels are different and the architecture is the same. Obedience to leadership is conditioned in small steps. Total trust is installed over years. Dissent is reframed as a personal failure. At the top of the staircase comes an instruction that ends lives, and it's obeyed because obedience itself has become the highest virtue.
None of those people thought they were in danger on the day they took the first small step. That's the whole point. By the time the dangerous instruction arrives, you've been trained for years not to be the kind of person who refuses it. Survival is tied to obedience. Then comes obedience to harder and harder instructions, then rehearsals, then the teaching that your doubt is sin. That combination has a body count. It isn't a neutral teaching.
Why the Exodus Argument Falls Apart
Now let me take the talk on its own ground: the Exodus. The whole talk leans on Moses. The Israelites obeyed strange instructions, such as don't break the lamb's bones, ask the Egyptians for gold, and camp against the Red Sea, and they were right to. So the argument goes that you should obey strange instructions from Jehovah's organization today.
Before the 10th plague, the Israelite families were instructed to slaughter a 1-year-old lamb. Roast the lamb. Don't boil it. Don't break any of its bones. Don't save any of it till morning. Burn the leftovers in the fire. And eat it with your belt fastened, sandals on your feet, staff in your hand, and eat it in a hurry. A lot of instructions. He says, "Go ask the Egyptians for articles of silver and gold and clothing." Now, did the Israelites object to this instruction? Could they have said, "Moses, don't you think this is bad timing? After all, the entire nation of Egypt, every household, has just lost their firstborn. And now we're going to ask them for their silver, their gold, and their clothing? Isn't that a little insensitive?"
Look at what's being compared. In the Exodus story the people were obeying God, and God had just authenticated himself in front of the entire nation with ten plagues the magicians couldn't copy, most of them anyway. The instructions were strange, sure, but the source had been proven publicly with evidence nobody could fake. The talk even admits this without noticing. It says that with each plague, Jehovah repeatedly showed he was using Moses. Exactly: proof first, obedience second.
Well, we have to remember this. With each plague, Jehovah repeatedly showed he was using Moses and Aaron. And has he not done so today? Think how during these difficult last days through disasters and wars and pandemics, we have repeatedly been guided by wise direction from Jehovah's organization, the faithful and discreet slave.
Look at the swap. The talk takes the obedience owed to a God who proved himself with miracles and transfers it onto Jehovah's organization, the faithful and discreet slave. The 2024 Watchtower already admitted that this means imperfect men, and the 2017 Watchtower admitted those same men have made mistakes in organizational direction. There are no plagues. There's no parted sea. There's a group of men in New York asking for the same unconditional, evidence-free obedience the Israelites gave to God, a God who had just turned a river into blood in front of Pharaoh. The argument only works if you don't notice that the Watchtower has quietly put itself in God's position.
But at that time, did the Israelites think, "Moses, excuse us, but you're giving us cooking instructions. Isn't this rather personal? I prefer to boil my meat, even if I have to break a few bones when I put it in the pot. I get indigestion if I have to eat in a hurry." Some possibly grumbled about it. But did they obey? Remarkably, yes. Jehovah told Moses to have the Israelites turn back and camp up against the Red Sea. Now, they were trapped between the Red Sea and Pharaoh's oncoming war chariots. Seem illogical? Dangerous? Or brilliant? You know the answer.
The cruelest part is the move we already saw: the 2024 article telling you that the feeling "this can't be from God" is a temptation to resist. In the Exodus, the people had proof. Today you have a directive from imperfect men who make mistakes and an instruction to distrust your own judgment about it. That isn't the faith of Moses. It's the opposite of what the Israelites did based on what they had.
Twenty Years of Escalation, in Their Own Words
Here's where 20 years of language has landed:
- 2007: keep in step.
- 2012: saved only if you obey.
- 2013: even if it doesn't appear sound.
- 2021: even if it makes no sense.
- 2022: even if you don't understand why.
- 2023: and by the way, COVID was practice.
- 2024: even though it comes from imperfect men, and your doubt is the real danger.
- 2026: even if it seems to put you in danger.
Every rung is tied to survival. Every rung removes one more reason a person might say no. The adjective for the instruction has climbed from unsound all the way to dangerous.
What Is the Rung Above "Dangerous"?
So I'll come back to the question I opened with, and it's worth sitting with, because the Watchtower has been answering it slowly for two decades. This organization has spent 20 years training millions of people to obey instructions that seem dangerous, and it has openly called past compliance a rehearsal for the real thing. What instruction is it rehearsing them for? What is the rung above dangerous? Are they headed for a Jonestown moment?
I hope not. I don't know what it will be, and neither do you. But I do know that the people being trained to obey it won't be allowed to ask. They've been taught that the question itself is the sin.
I also want to be careful not to overreach. I'm not going to tell you that a room full of men schemed this out on a whiteboard. I don't know if they did, and neither does anybody else. The simplified edition being blunter might be nothing more than what happens when you simplify language, since blunt is simpler than nuanced. This argument doesn't need a master villain, and that's exactly why it deserves your attention rather than your dismissal. Maybe this ladder was built on purpose. Maybe it drifted there one reasonable-sounding article at a time, with nobody at headquarters quite noticing. Either way, the person sitting in the chair gets conditioned the same.
Lifton's whole point is that this usually isn't a conspiracy. It happens one step at a time, and no one sees a staircase. The most effective version doesn't need anybody to be evil. It needs 20 years and an audience that has never been shown the steps side by side.
This article is a written companion to the video above from the ExJW Analyzer YouTube channel. Every claim is sourced in the full reference document (PDF). Watch the full video, or explore the research wiki for sourced, primary-document analysis.
← More video breakdowns